{"config":{"moduleinfo":{"javascripts_count":[{"count_phone":0,"count":0}],"styles_count":[{"count_phone":0,"count":0}],"htmls_count":[{"count_phone":2,"count":2}]},"htmls":[],"styles":[{"text":".aliyun-topbar .aliyun-topbar-header .aliyun-topbar-element.sub-logo .sub-logo-link .sub-logo-image{height:22px !important;}"},{"text":".aliyun-topbar .aliyun-topbar-header .aliyun-topbar-element.sub-logo .sub-logo-link.pointer{display: flex;align-items:center;}"},{"text":".aliyun-topbar .aliyun-topbar-header .aliyun-topbar-element.aliyun-language{display:none !important;}"},{"text":".aliyun-topbar {box-shadow: none !important;}"}],"javascripts":[{"text":"function isDingTalkFn() { var ua = navigator.userAgent.toLowerCase(); var isIn = /dingtalk/gi.test(ua); if (isIn) { var style = document.createElement(\"style\"); style.innerText = ` @media (max-width: 768px) { .aliyun-module.wb-aliyun-developer-h5-nav { display: none!important; } .aliyun-module[data-module-name=\"@ali/hmod-ace-homepage-2020-hmod-footer\"] { display: none; } } `; document.head.appendChild(style); } }; isDingTalkFn();"}],"countinfo":{"htmls":{"length_pc":0,"length":0}},"header":"activity","logo":"https://img.alicdn.com/tfs/TB1KR.SwYr1gK0jSZFDXXb9yVXa-160-40.png","logoLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/"},"settings":{"uuid":"NOUUID"}}
中国站
联系我们
ICP备案控制台登录/注册
{"config":{"moduleinfo":{"question":"","rightTitle":"个人中心","menu_count":[{"count_phone":8,"count":8}],"article":"","rightMenu_count":[{"count_phone":3,"count":3}]},"menu":[{"menuTitle":"出发吧创业者","menuLink":"https://startup.aliyun.com/special/gostartup"},{"ismoreList":false,"menuTitle":"首页","menuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com"},{"menuTitle":"资讯","ismoreList":false,"menuTag":"","menuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/info/","submenu":[]},{"menuTitle":"融资","menuLink":"","ismoreList":true,"menuTag":"","submenu":[{"submenuTitle":"","submenuLink":"","morsubemenu":[{"morsubemenuTitle":"投BP","morsubemenuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/company/"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"源码资本","morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/financing/sourcecodecap"},{"morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/financing/gaorongvc","morsubemenuTitle":"高榕资本"},{"morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/financing/brv","morsubemenuTitle":"蓝驰创投"},{"morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/financing/ebvc","morsubemenuTitle":"钟鼎创投"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"元璟创投","morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/financing/visionpluscapital"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"靖亚资本","morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/financing/emventures"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"清流资本","morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/financing/crystalstreamcap"}],"moresubmenuTitle":"找融资"},{"submenuTitle":"","submenuLink":"","morsubemenu":[{"morsubemenuTitle":"专精特新直通北交所","morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/startup-program/zjtx"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"线下园区入驻","morsubemenuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/city"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"赛道明星班","morsubemenuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/star"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"赛道训练营","morsubemenuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/demoday"}],"moresubmenuTitle":"加速与孵化"}]},{"ismoreList":true,"submenu":[{"submenuTitle":"","submenuLink":"","morsubemenu":[{"morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/special/newstartups","morsubemenuTitle":"项目求报道"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"大企业创新场景对接","morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/openinnovation"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"IoT框架技术内测","morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/waft"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"阿里生态资源对接","morsubemenuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/markets/aliyun/surpportive"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"深圳千万上云补贴扶持","morsubemenuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/szwqsy/"}],"moresubmenuTitle":"资源对接"},{"submenuTitle":"","submenuLink":"","morsubemenu":[{"morsubemenuTitle":"创业大赛","morsubemenuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/event"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"88帮帮节","morsubemenuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/special/88"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"创业节","morsubemenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/chuangyejie/1111/2021"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"创峰会","morsubemenuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/chuangfenghui"},{"morsubemenuTitle":"云栖TechDay","morsubemenuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/techday"}],"moresubmenuTitle":"热门活动"}],"menuTitle":"资源与活动","menuLink":""},{"menuTitle":"城市站","menuLink":"","ismoreList":false,"submenu":[{"submenuLink":"https://startup.aliyun.com/city/nb/","submenuTitle":"宁波海曙站"},{"submenuLink":"//startup.aliyun.com/city/vanke-wanchuang/portal","submenuTitle":"万创科技城站"},{"submenuTitle":"聊城城市站","submenuLink":"//startup.aliyun.com/city/lc/portal/"},{"submenuTitle":"太原城市站","submenuLink":"//startup.aliyun.com/city/ty/portal"},{"submenuLink":"//startup.aliyun.com/city/xt/","submenuTitle":"湘潭城市站"},{"submenuLink":"//startup.aliyun.com/city/zz/","submenuTitle":"郑州城市站"},{"submenuTitle":"岳阳城市站","submenuLink":"//startup.aliyun.com/city/yy/"},{"submenuTitle":"上海金桥站","submenuLink":"https://startup.aliyun.com/city/sh/"},{"submenuTitle":"成都","submenuLink":"https://startup.aliyun.com/city/cd/"},{"submenuTitle":"镇江","submenuLink":"https://startup.aliyun.com/city/zj/"}]},{"menuTitle":"活动中心","menuLink":"//startup.aliyun.com/event","menuTag":"","submenu":[],"ismoreList":false},{"menuTitle":"创业白皮书","menuTag":"","menuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/special/ebook"},{"menuTitle":"更多服务","menuLink":"","ismoreList":false,"submenu":[{"submenuTitle":"政策指南平台","submenuLink":"https://sme.aliyun.com/policy/"},{"submenuTitle":"创业直播间","submenuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/live/"},{"submenuLink":"//market.aliyun.com/shuangchuang","submenuTitle":"创业服务市场"},{"submenuTitle":"人才招聘","submenuLink":"//edu.aliyun.com/recruit"},{"submenuTitle":"云栖大会科技专场","submenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/special/yunqi/2021/live"}]},{"menuTitle":"直播间","menuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/live/","submenu":[{"submenuTitle":"云谷创新谈","submenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/live/room/4"},{"submenuTitle":"星云计划公开课","submenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/live/room/2"},{"submenuTitle":"一汽奔腾“智“”悦”座舱云上对接会","submenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/live/video/250792"},{"submenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/live/video/250721","submenuTitle":"钉钉专场:钉钉PaaS开放及生态策略"}]},{"menuTitle":"中小企业服务平台","menuLink":"https://sme.aliyun.com/"},{"menuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/brand/duoguan/","menuTitle":"品牌馆","submenu":[{"submenuTitle":"IT桔子","submenuLink":"https://startup.aliyun.com/brand/itjuzi/"},{"submenuTitle":"夺冠","submenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/brand/duoguan/"},{"submenuTitle":"蓝驰创投","submenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/financing/brv"},{"submenuTitle":"高榕资本","submenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/financing/gaorongvc"},{"submenuTitle":"元璟资本","submenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/financing/visionpluscapital/"},{"submenuTitle":"源码资本","submenuLink":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/financing/sourcecodecap/"}]},{}],"rightMenu":[{"menuTitle":"我的项目","menuLink":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/project/my"}],"countinfo":{"menu":{"length_pc":0,"length":0},"rightMenu":{"length_pc":0,"length":0}},"publicity":{"img":"","link":""}},"settings":{"uuid":"NOUUID"}}
{"config":{"moduleinfo":{"searchLink":"//m.aliyun.com/product/search","channels_count":[{"count_phone":12,"count":12}],"searchText":"ecs","noAppDownload":true,"logo":"//gw.alicdn.com/tps/TB11eICOFXXXXaLapXXXXXXXXXX-130-39.png"},"channels":[{"spmId":"0","maxShowNum":"6","isOpenSubChannel":false,"link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/","title":"首页"},{"spmId":"0","maxShowNum":"6","isOpenSubChannel":false,"link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/info/","title":"创业资讯"},{"link":"","title":"找融资","subChannels":[{"title":"投BP","link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/company/"},{"title":"云融资","link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/product/financing"}],"isOpenSubChannel":true},{"spmId":"0","channelStr":"频道描述","maxShowNum":"6","isOpenSubChannel":false,"link":"","title":"孵化与加速","subChannels":[{"title":"线下园区入驻","link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/city"},{"spmId":"0","tce_rule_count":"1","link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/star","title":"AI赛道明星班"},{"spmId":"0","tce_rule_count":"1","link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/demoday","title":"赛道训练营"}]},{"spmId":"0","maxShowNum":"0","isOpenSubChannel":false,"title":"资源对接","subChannels":[{"title":"大企业创新场景对接","link":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/openinnovation"},{"link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/markets/aliyun/surpportive","title":"阿里生态资源对接"},{"link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/szwqsy/","title":"深圳千万上云补贴"}],"link":""},{"link":"","title":"走进城市站","isOpenSubChannel":false,"subChannels":[{"link":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/city/vanke-wanchuang/portal","title":"万创科技城"},{"link":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/city/lc/portal/","title":"聊城城市站"},{"link":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/city/ty/portal","title":"太原城市站"},{"title":"湘潭城市站","link":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/city/xt/portal"},{"title":"郑州城市站","link":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/city/zz/portal"},{"title":"岳阳城市站","link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/city/yy/"},{"title":"上海金桥站","link":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/city/sh/"}]},{"spmId":"0","maxShowNum":"6","isOpenSubChannel":false,"link":"","title":"热门活动","subChannels":[{"title":"创业大赛","link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/event"},{"title":"88帮帮节","link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/special/88"},{"title":"创业节","link":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/special/chuangyejie/spring2021"},{"title":"创峰会","link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/chuangfenghui"},{"link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/techday/","title":"云栖Techday"}]},{"link":"","title":"更多","isOpenSubChannel":false,"subChannels":[{"title":"求报道","link":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/resource/apply/8/140#/"},{"title":"创业直播间","link":"//chuangke.aliyun.com/live/"},{"link":"//market.aliyun.com/shuangchuang","title":"创业服务市场"},{"title":"人才招聘","link":"//edu.aliyun.com/recruit"}]}],"countinfo":{"channels":{"length_pc":0,"length":0}}},"settings":{"uuid":"NOUUID","recommend":{"visibleMode":"default"},"anchor":{"visibleMode":"all"},"pc":{"background":"","horizontal":"默认","verticalNumber":0,"marginTop":"","marginBottom":"","contentBackground":"","paddingHoz":"","paddingTop":"","paddingBottom":"","backgroundImage":"","autoHeight":false},"h5":{"background":"","horizontal":"默认","verticalNumber":0,"marginTop":"","marginBottom":"","contentBackground":"","paddingHoz":"","paddingTop":"","paddingBottom":"","backgroundImage":"","autoHeight":false}}}
{"config":{"adConfig":{"target":"_blank","pcImg":"","h5Img":"","icon":"","mode":"all","extraList":[],"linkList":[],"href":""},"windowSet":{"open":true,"dataList":[{"list":[{"url":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/special/newstartups","text":"求报道"},{"url":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/company/","text":"找融资"}]},{"list":[{"text":"创企榜","url":"https://chuangke.aliyun.com/special/startup"}],"bgi":"https://img.alicdn.com/imgextra/i3/O1CN01vevPS31ofSq4izkDg_!!6000000005252-2-tps-84-232.png","color":"#fff"}]}},"settings":{"recommend":{"visibleMode":"default"},"anchor":{"visibleMode":"all"},"pc":{"background":"","horizontal":"默认","verticalNumber":0,"marginTop":"0","marginBottom":"0","contentBackground":"","paddingHoz":"0","paddingTop":"0","paddingBottom":"0","backgroundImage":"","autoHeight":false},"h5":{"background":"","horizontal":"默认","verticalNumber":0,"marginTop":"0","marginBottom":"0","contentBackground":"","paddingHoz":"0","paddingTop":"0","paddingBottom":"0","backgroundImage":"","autoHeight":false}}}
扫码加钉群 十万创业者 与你为伴

葡萄中的爱马仕,为啥不香了

阳光玫瑰变便宜了,也变难吃了

每年9月左右,“阳光玫瑰”在水果圈的存在感爆棚。

没别的原因,这个月的“阳光玫瑰”格外便宜。你在大型农贸批发市场可以找到5、6块一斤的阳光玫瑰,也可以在商超见到9.9元一斤的打折阳光玫瑰。

阳光玫瑰,突然从一种奢侈品变成大众平价款。

阳光玫瑰为什么降价这么厉害?便宜的阳光玫瑰跟贵价的相比,有啥区别?

阳光玫瑰,一年比一年便宜了

几年前,“阳光玫瑰”第一次在国内上市,就因为价格高达200~300元/串,喜提“葡萄中的爱马仕”称号。那时候,普通人只有在女明星秀恩爱的微博里,一睹“阳光玫瑰”的风采。

这几年,阳光玫瑰逐渐走下神坛。

比起它初来乍到时动辄300/斤的价格,10~20元/斤的价格已经十分常见。

我们能强烈感受到,阳光玫瑰确实便宜了,至少变成了普通人能消费得起的水果。

那么,这几年阳光玫瑰到底便宜了多少?

事实上,阳光玫瑰降价已经持续了好几年。今年并不是最便宜的一年。

我们爬取了北京新发地农产品市场2020~2022年阳光玫瑰的所有价格公示数据。结果发现,2020年、2021年、2022新发地的阳光玫瑰平均批发价分别为26.7元、22.3元、25.0元[1]。

这样的价格,远低于同期的车厘子。

也就是说,阳光玫瑰降价已经持续很长一段时间了,去年的阳光玫瑰降价比今年还狠。

不过,整个阳光玫瑰批发市场两极分化的现象一直存在。比如,2022年,新发地阳光玫瑰最低批发价仅仅5元/斤,最高是55元/斤,贵的和便宜的能相差数十倍。

之所以9月阳光玫瑰的存在感格外高,是因为一年中阳光玫瑰的价格不断波动,往往在这个月形成一个价格低谷。

一般来说,3-5月时阳光玫瑰会达到一年中的价格高峰。比如,2022年,新发地阳光玫瑰3-5月均价都在30元以上/斤,达到了一个小高峰。但一进入6月价格就开始滑坡了。7月、8月大幅降价之后,到9月时均价已经腰斩到12.1元/斤。

为什么阳光玫瑰这几年价格跳水这么严重?9月的阳光玫瑰为什么这么便宜?

阳光玫瑰价格下降,是必然的

在回答阳光玫瑰为啥大幅降价之前,我们必须先回答另一个问题:阳光玫瑰一开始为什么会卖出天价?

阳光玫瑰确实大有来头。

它诞生的日本,本身是没有可以作为经济栽培的葡萄,不过日本极为擅长杂交葡萄。追溯“阳光玫瑰”的身世,历经了11年,是一部漫长的跨国品种“孕育史”。

“阳光玫瑰”又被叫做“夏音马卡斯特(Shine—Muscat)”、“安艺津23号”,属于欧美种杂交的“混血儿”,是美洲系葡萄“安艺津21”和欧洲系葡萄“白南”的后代。“阳光玫瑰”兼顾了种植和美味,在2003年9月被登记命名为“阳光麝香”,2009年在日本国内正式推广[2-3]。

很多人第一次知道“阳光玫瑰”,可能是大名鼎鼎的“晴王”。如果说“阳光玫瑰”是“葡萄中的爱马仕”,那“晴王”就是“爱马仕中的顶配”。

其实,“晴王”并不是一个品种,它更像是一个“品牌名”,特指在日本冈山县种出来的“阳光玫瑰”。这个地方不仅阳光充足,日照时间长,雨水也很好,简直是葡萄的“宜居地”,种在这里糖分、香气噌噌往上涨。

不过,“晴王”的产量不高,同样一亩地,“晴王”产量只有普通葡萄的十分之一。

这样生长出来的“阳光玫瑰”吃起来就像薄皮爆汁的果冻,咬下去的瞬间汁水流溢,带着阳光与花朵的明媚香气在口中绽开,让人回味无穷。所以“晴王”也比其他地区要贵上几倍,甚至出现过50元一颗的情况,是真正的“天价”葡萄[3]。

一开始贵得离谱的阳光玫瑰,更多是指这种日本进口来的“晴王”。

2006年,中国开始开展引种工作。2007年12月,“阳光玫瑰”就在浙江金华“落户”。最开始,它也有些“怕生”,有着果穗品质不一,果实营养不良、玫瑰香味淡,以及病虫害等各种问题[4]。

直到2017年,阳光玫瑰才算真正本土化成功。中科院农业科学院果树研究所还研制出了一种能使“阳光玫瑰”果子大,还去核的有机物调节粉剂,让果实增重了4~5g,品质也上去了。

2018年,云南一家农业公司种植的8亩阳光玫瑰总销售额达128万元、亩产值16万元,实现了“年入百万”[3]。而在其他地方,阳光玫瑰也为种植户带来6~7万元/亩的经济效益[5]。

利润惊人的阳光玫瑰,就这样迅速的在中国其他省域推广种植,短短5年就在34个省域开花结果。

种植面积就像滚雪球似的扩增,是让“阳光玫瑰”价格下降最重要的原因。据一项产业分析数据报告显示,2021年全国阳光玫瑰种植面积约为31.21万亩,收获面积约为20.42万亩,相比于2016年种植面积10.01万亩,足足增长了21.2万亩,增幅达211.79%[3],增种面积有近2万个足球场那大。

因为种植区域的跨度实在太大,所以各地国产阳光玫瑰成熟上市时间不尽相同。

3~4月北方都还是一片枯败萧瑟,云南河谷地带的“阳光玫瑰”一枝独秀开始上市,直到5~6月才能采摘完。这也导致这个时期的阳光玫瑰最贵。

6月底,云南的果农刚歇下,广西、广东的“阳光玫瑰”纷纷登场;8月,暑气正盛,湖南地区“阳光玫瑰”的采摘如火如荼。随后同纬度的四川、重庆、江浙沪地区,“阳光玫瑰”陆续上市[3]。

8、9月份阳光玫瑰大量上市,才导致阳光玫瑰价格暴跌。

如今,在日本十分娇贵、稀有的阳光玫瑰,在国内几实现了“量产”和一年四季的无间断供应。总之,“阳光玫瑰”价格下降是必然的,只是时间问题而已。

变便宜的阳光玫瑰,可能没那么好吃了

阳光玫瑰降价,很多人终于吃上了这个昔日的水果贵族。然而,花了几十块买回家,却发现并没有想象中的惊艳,甚至有点涩口,更尝不出来什么“玫瑰香”。

其实,国产阳光玫瑰价格两级分化,质量上同样如此。

利益驱动之下,大量地区加入到阳光玫瑰种植的队伍里。但并不是所有地方的自然地理环境都得天独厚。“橘生淮南则为橘,生于淮北则为枳”,阳光玫瑰同样如此。

一项2022年最新研究,对比中国14个种植基地的阳光玫瑰果实差异。

首先,不同产地的阳光玫瑰外观上就能拉开很大差距。比如,下图从左数第11个,是南方浙江金华生长出来阳光玫瑰,果粒大,颜色黄绿;左数第2个,是河北石家庄生长出来的,果粒小,颜色青绿[6]。

中国14个产地阳光玫瑰的外观差异很大[5]

两者的口感也存在差异。实验中,金华阳光玫瑰的固酸比要远高于石家庄产地的。而固酸比越高,往往意味着风味越强烈。

所以,在不同月份,你花不同的价钱买到不同产地的阳光玫瑰,口感可能差异很大。

除此之外,不同种植基地的种植技术也良莠不齐。

为了得到果粒更大、产量更高的阳光玫瑰,一些种植者选择牺牲一部分风味,以换取好价钱。

拿肥料这一项来说,在日本原产地,“阳光玫瑰”多采用的是植物源的有机物,比如木屑、核桃壳等。但是在国内,大多数情况下用的是动物源性的有机肥,比如动物粪便。有的果农为了节省成本,利用无机肥,比如磷肥、钾肥、钙肥[3]。

的确,阳光玫瑰的果粒大了,丰产,但香气消失,甜度拔高,少了一份清爽。

为了追求外观上的果粒更大,果农们还会用一些膨大剂长个头,大是大了,看起来也漂亮,但少有玫瑰香味,偶尔还有空心的现象[7]。

阳光玫瑰的早摘同样普遍。

前面提到,3-5月时阳光玫瑰售价最高。为了抢占这个“尝鲜”的先机,有的果农会在果实尚未完全成熟之前采摘。

浙江“阳光玫瑰”葡萄应从8月初开始采摘。8月7日采摘的阳光玫瑰葡萄,其可溶性糖含量约为70 mg/gFW左右,苹果酸含量为1 mg/gFW左右;而若在7月17日提前采摘,其可溶性糖含量仅为50 mg/gFW左右,苹果酸含量却达到了5 mg/gFW左右[8]。

也就早摘20天左右,糖酸比已经出现巨大差距。

你在网上看到的“不够甜”、“有些酸涩”等差评,很可能就是因为他们吃了这些早摘的“阳光玫瑰”。

所以,阳光玫瑰就算真的跌到“白菜价”,你也别以为可以薅到果农的羊毛。阳光玫瑰晒过的每一缕阳光,早就暗中标好了价格。

参考文献

[1]数据来源:北京市新发地农产品批发市场信息

[2]李明. (2021). 阳光玫瑰葡萄的引种表现和优质栽培技术. 中国南方果树, 50(3), 4.

[3]云果产业大脑.(2022).2022年中国阳光玫瑰葡萄产业数据分析报告.

[4]陈晓丽. (2020). 阳光玫瑰葡萄在我国的引种表现及研究进展. 农业与技术, 40(4), 4.

[5]陈湘云, 王先荣, 石雪晖, 张强鑫, 郭光银, & 戴述雄等. (2019). "阳光玫瑰"葡萄生物学特性及其栽培关键技术. 湖南农业科学(8), 4.

[6]王令宇, 刘畅, 房经贵, 上官凌飞, 杨毓贤, & 叶东东等. (2022). 我国阳光玫瑰葡萄果实品质性状调查分析. 山西农业科学(050-007).

[7]聂瑞洁. (2021). '阳光玫瑰'葡萄未来市场形势分析.

[8]李海燕. (2017). '阳光玫瑰'葡萄香气物质积累规律及其调控研究. (Doctoral dissertation, 浙江大学).